
As National Preparedness Month comes to a close, we’re focusing our Housing is Health blog on the link between housing and the effects of the climate crisis. Healthcare professionals can advocate for patients experiencing housing instability or hardship by providing personal preparedness guidance, continuity of care during natural disasters, and assistance with accessing community resources that support stable, affordable housing.
Natural disasters – like floods, hurricanes, and wildfires – can have wide-ranging, long-term structural and economic impacts. Hurricane Katrina, for example, demonstrated that disaster events can cripple communities and stifle recovery for decades to come. Although the community is still recovering, it was in the immediate aftermath of Katrina that residents of the Gulf Coast experienced the hurricane’s most devastating effects. According to a Brookings Institute report, over a million residents of the region were displaced by the storm, with some facing prolonged stays in motels, shelters, or temporary housing. Many residents were able to return to their homes within a few days, but those who already experienced socio-economic adversity faced seemingly insurmountable challenges. Home repairs were well outside many families’ financial resources, available housing shrunk, and already-compromised public housing buildings were destroyed. Low-income families impacted by Hurricane Katrina still struggle to regain what was lost. In the years since, we’ve seen this phenomenon with increasing frequency, in Puerto Rico, Texas, and the Southeastern U.S. Experts acknowledge that this trend will only worsen as climate change accelerates and aggravates natural disasters across the globe.
As global temperatures continue to rise, specific regions are facing more frequent and prolonged heat waves. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports that extreme heat kills over 600 people across the U.S. each year – a number that is expected to grow as the climate crisis worsens. Heat waves are especially dangerous for already vulnerable populations, like children, people with disabilities, and senior citizens. Despite this risk, and the over-representation of these populations in public housing, public housing authorities are not mandated to provide air conditioners to residents of federally-supported housing, or maintain utility costs associated with air conditioner use. The vast majority (75%) of residents of public housing have extremely low incomes, a barrier that not only limits access to air conditioning units, but restricts residents’ ability to financially manage ongoing utility costs. Some cities have launched programs aimed at addressing this disparity, like the New York City Public Housing Authority’s pilot project announced in the summer of 2019. Yet as heat waves become more commonplace in America’s largest cities, something as simple as air conditioning can tip the scales of survival for millions.
In September of 2018, The Guardian reported that low-income residents of Flagstaff, Arizona are in the throes of “climate gentrification,” a term that is used to describe an increasingly common consequence of the climate crisis. As the effects of global warming (including more natural disasters and heat waves) are felt across the country, wealthier individuals residing in areas of greatest impact are able to relocate to relatively safe, risk-free areas (like Flagstaff). Low-income families with limited financial means are effectively “stuck” in disaster-prone neighborhoods, while the influx of wealth to relocation zones raises rent prices and property values. Like its original namesake, climate gentrification has a tendency to displace those already at increased socio-economic risk, including populations with a higher likelihood of adverse effects due to the climate crisis and related natural disasters.
America is undergoing an affordable housing crisis. The problem is twofold: there is a shortage of available housing for low-income families, and the cost of housing across the U.S. has steadily outpaced wage growth. The effects of global warming are set to exacerbate this growing crisis, as individuals at or below the poverty line spend more and more on rent with less income to spare on emergency preparedness and recovery. As climate gentrification and climate-related migration accelerate, population changes will crowd and increase the price of areas already experiencing housing shortages. Without access to reliable, affordable housing, families have little recourse when faced with displacement or other adverse natural disaster outcomes.
While the majority of Americans receiving federal housing assistance utilize community-based rental subsidies (like the Housing Choice Voucher program), close to two million people still reside in traditional public housing developments. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) constructed most of today’s extant public housing complexes over forty years ago, with little (if any) consistent funding for upkeep and improvement. As a result, residents of traditional public housing are particularly susceptible to the damage caused by natural disasters. These vulnerable structures house populations at an increased risk for the climate crisis’ effects, including senior citizens and people with disabilities. An interdisciplinary approach will be necessary to mitigate ongoing effects of global warming, including renewed investment in our public housing infrastructure.
The climate crisis is creating new patient needs that will only worsen as time goes on. What can health centers do to support patients before and during natural disasters?

Substance use disorders (SUDs) are illnesses that affect a person’s brain and behavior, leading to the inability to control the use of a legal or illegal drug or medication. The scope and effects of SUDs are complex, but there is no mistaking the impact that they have on the population. Research has established that a person’s access to safe, affordable housing affects their health outcomes. For individuals with SUD, access may be inhibited by pervasive stigma, punitive laws and policies, and lack of appropriate resources.
Lack of stable housing causes stress that often leads to poor health outcomes, especially for those suffering from SUDs. There is an overrepresentation of mental illness and substance use within urban populations experiencing homelessness, with estimates of the prevalence of SUDs between 29-75%. Punitive responses to and criminalization of the behaviors of people who use drugs remain a significant factor in the housing issues people with SUDs face. State and local policies and programs shape housing, but mostly national policies dictate what happens to people with SUDs and their family members. Federal laws mandate that public housing authorities and owners establish policies that allow for the eviction of entire households if as few as one member is using illicit drugs (read full list of criteria: here). Other laws target people with SUDs, making it difficult for them to find a home. A current bill, H.R. 2179: Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients, would require individuals to pass a drug test before eligibility for Section 8 rental assistance and public housing. Federal regulations allow housing authorities to consider drug use and convictions of people and/or their family members when making decisions to evict or deny access to federally subsidized housing. Stigma against individuals with SUDs displays its negative effects through policy both federally and locally.
Individuals with SUDs can access free market rentals with housing subsidies (e.g., the Housing Choice Voucher Program), but there is little research to document success or discrimination in response to their efforts. To solve this problem, we need to frame this discussion around the continuum of care for people with SUDs, primarily focusing on the different types of housing opportunities and services available. It’s important to begin with a differentiation of the types of recovery: (b) Aspirational/Harm Reduction recovery – abstinence is not the current goal, but the individual can visualize that as a goal as some future point. These individuals still wish to reduce harm associated with the use of substances and improve other aspects of their lives. There isn’t a “one size fits all” solution for those struggling with SUDs. Communities must ensure that their recovery housing programs accept and serve people at all stages of recovery, including those still using alcohol and drugs.
SUDs involving alcohol and illicit drugs are strongly associated with homelessness, with prevalence sometimes exceeding 50% in community samples. There have been many approaches to assisting individuals experiencing homelessness with co-occurring SUDs. Abstinence-oriented recovery homes, also called sober living houses (SLHs), are an option for persons with substance use problems hoping to abstain from substances on their program of recovery. SLHs are promoted as places to send clients to live after they complete residential treatment. SLHs are considered housing that fits in with single/multi-family neighborhoods and mixed-use residential-commercial areas. Recent research indicates that there have been favorable outcomes for individuals involved in this model, but there are significant limitations. One of the major limitations stems from the requirement for individuals to remain abstinent, which some people are unable to do. SLHs can provide a supportive environment for people in recovery, but as in traditional public housing, if residents can’t demonstrate their continued sobriety, they can be evicted. Meeting individuals where they are and working through their process is an important step in housing people with substance use problems.
Housing First uses a harm reduction approach, which focuses on reducing harm caused by the individual’s substance use and behavioral health issues. Immediate access to free or subsidized housing without requiring transitional steps or demonstrated sobriety is a main tenet of this philosophy. The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) has begun to shift its approach to center around Housing First, as evidenced by its Continuum of Care (CoC) Program. There has been a demonstrated need for this low-demand approach, and the results have been promising. Reviews of the research on Housing First have indicated that when people experiencing homelessness are able to access free or subsidized apartments they are prone to stay in those locations for extended periods. Offering housing first and implementing case management services thereafter has spurred favorable outcomes for many individuals. Moreover, studies have demonstrated that people in the Housing First model with a serious mental illness, SUD, or co-occurring mental illness and SUD have demonstrated similar or better housing stability and recovery outcomes, compared to those placed in housing with pre-requisites like sobriety.
The stigma faced by those people with SUDs is manifested through policies that further exacerbate their situation and, in turn, detract from recovery. This issue is systemic and demands a multi-faceted response. If you work in a health center, providing information about Housing First opportunities in your community to patients is critically important. Each individual has their own set of needs, and providing these potential avenues of support can be vital in their recovery. It is equally important to advocate for the rights of people with SUDs. There are efforts that intersect with this issue, such as Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s and Sen. Kamala Harris’ collaboration to fight housing discrimination. Groups such as Treatment Communities of America (TCA) have created reports outlining the data and advocacy necessary to eliminate the lack of stable housing for those suffering with SUDs. Housing is health, and there are many ways to achieve positive health outcomes for those with substance use related issues. In order to ensure those outcomes, the individual’s needs must be emphasized in policy through harm reduction strategies that are not punitive and free of stigma.
Fewer than 2 symptoms = no disorder; 2-3 = mild disorder; 4-5 = moderate disorder; 6 or more = severe disorder.
Bianca Chun contributed to this post.

The harmful effects of lead on the human body has been well-chronicled and documented throughout history. Lead is a cumulative toxicant that irreversibly affects multiple body systems and makes its way into the blood, particularly affecting the development of the brain and nervous system as children grow into adolescence and adulthood. Once these high levels of exposure occur in children there is an increased chance of a reduction in IQ, behavioral changes such as reduced attention span, and increased antisocial behavior, among other health effects. There is no safe blood lead concentration for children, but the Center for Disease Control and Prevention has adopted an accepted blood lead level:
In May 2012, the CDC accepted the recommendation from the Advisory Committee on Lead Poisoning Prevention to eliminate the term “level of concern” and to begin using a reference value of 5 micrograms per deciliter based on the 97.5 percentile of the blood lead distribution among U.S. children.
Lead can be found in a variety of places (water, soil, air, gasoline, etc.), but the most endemic source of lead poisoning today remains lead paint present in public and private housing. Older housing structures (those built before 1978) that have lead-based paint continue to deteriorate over time, exposing young children to its harmful effects (mainly in the form of lead dust and paint chips that are ingested). There have been concerns about lead paint for decades. At the start of the 20th Century a Sherwin-Williams publication called white lead “a deadly cumulative poison.” Before that, Benjamin Franklin warned of the effects of lead poison in the human body in a 1786 letter – nearly 200 years before lead-based house paint was banned by the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC).
Now, why is this still an issue for many children and families today if lead’s deleterious effects were reported so long ago? In his book Doubt is their Product: How Industry’s Assault on Science Threatens Your Health, David Michaels argues that though lead was regarded as a highly toxic chemical in the 1900s, it took some time before facts penetrated the minds and actions of government leaders. This delay was due in large part to the persistent messaging of paint production companies and PR agencies touting lead’s safety, a campaign not unlike the misinformation propagated by tobacco companies throughout the 20th century. It wasn’t until there was overwhelming evidence that lead affected industry workers and average Americans (including children) that the CPSC took action in 1978. Since this moment, there has been a significant decline in lead poisoning rates (nationally and statewide) among children through lead remediation efforts, education, and other interventions, but there remains a significant gap in outcomes for those living in low-income, disadvantaged areas.
Despite the steps taken nationally and locally to curb the effects lead has on children and their families, the chart below illustrates the continued prevalence of negative health outcomes as a result of lead exposure.
In 2004, 12 percent of children tested in Philadelphia had levels of 10 or more micrograms per deciliter of lead in the blood; by 2014, that figure dropped to 1.7 percent. On its face, this looks and sounds like a success, but a closer look shows there are still communities hit hard by the effects of lead.
CDC describes children who are African-American, living in poverty, enrolled in Medicaid, and living in older housing as having the highest risk for lead exposure. This description is very apt when discussing Philadelphia, as this group, along with Hispanics, face lead exposure at disproportionate rates compared to Caucasians in the city. Approximately 85 to 92 percent of the city’s housing units were built before the 1978 federal ban on lead-based paint. Compared to the rest of the nation (where just over 50 percent of homes were built prior to that year), it becomes easier to see why this issue persists. Couple this with Philadelphia being the poorest big city in the country (with over 25 percent of people living in poverty and residing in deteriorated homes), and the picture becomes just a bit clearer.


In the city of Philadelphia, as in many U.S. cities, rental assistance is provided to low-income families to live in the private rental market through the Housing Choice Voucher Program, which is funded by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). This public housing decentralization trend is not only privatizing a formerly public system, but may be seen as an attempt to promote freedom of housing and to integrate lower-income and minority families into mainstream society. Voucher programs aim to move many residents of public housing from high-rise public housing structures to the private market, but do not necessarily address the concern that this segment of the population has already been exposed to significant levels of lead and continues to suffer its effects. Moreover, there is no guarantee that voucher-based housing will be lead-free (as we’ll discuss later). Philadelphia has established laws and regulations to limit the effects of lead on vulnerable communities. Below, we’ll discuss why these safeguards have not sufficiently addressed this issue to date, and outline promising practices and models that can create meaningful change.
There are laws currently in place in the city that have been largely effective in reducing lead poisoning over the years, but there are enforceable laws on the books that are not being enforced, leading to large swaths of children being affected at unacceptable rates. The city’s current lead paint disclosure law mandates that property owners ensure their constructed buildings that pre-date 1978 are certified as lead-safe if they are occupied by a child 6 years old or younger. Despite this mandate, many apartments and homes remain untested. Philadelphia has approximately 5,800 unexpired lead-safe certifications on file, but children 6 and younger reside in an estimated 22,000 rental properties throughout the city. This alone illustrates the shortfall of untested rental units that need to be certified lead-safe, with the enforcement of this law falling well short of its intended goal. There continues to be calls for the city to enforce the laws on the books to hold landlords accountable, but (i.e. having trouble reaching negligent landlords because of concealed identities through LLCs, lack of streamlined proactive process in inspecting high-risk neighborhoods, etc.). Because of this, last year City Council passed two pieces of legislation tied to lead safety that focused on negligent landlords.
Sam Magavern published an article in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, where he took readers on a deep dive of the housing stock in Buffalo and Rochester. These cities have had similar issues with poverty and old, deteriorated housing structures that are riddled with lead-based paint. Many of the solutions proposed in this article are relevant to Philadelphia, and some have already been implemented and have shown results. One that has been echoed by many in Philadelphia is the need for proactive housing inspections. This means not relying solely on complaint-based inspections as a strategy to protect residents of public and private housing from dilapidated, dangerous rental units that can expose children to lead, but adopting universal inspections across the board. Also, it would eliminate the fear that many residents of public housing have of complaining because they don’t want to be evicted for voicing their displeasure and concerns. As mentioned, in Philadelphia there are many who have advocated for this process to be mandated as law.
In the past decade, Philadelphia has taken important steps to remediate the lead issue in all levels of housing (including public housing), but there is still much more work to do. For example, Philadelphia Department of Public Health’s Lead and Healthy Homes Program has implemented numerous initiatives to improve the health and safety of housing in the city. Even with this in place, there are still blindspots that need to be addressed as it relates to public housing in the city of Philadelphia. Below you will find some recommendations found on this topic that have been discussed here so far (and some that have not):
Lead-based Paint Abatement: Full removal of lead-based paint regardless of whether or not there is a child 6 years old or younger living at residence. Resulting renovations may be costly upfront, but would be the most effective way to prevent long-term health effects for children. According to the EPA, professional lead-based paint removal would cost about $8 to $15 per square foot or about $9,600 to $30,000 for a 1,200- to 2,000-sq. ft. house. The average removal project costs about $10,000. Also as a frame of reference, in recent years Congress recently directed $170 million in aid to Flint. That's roughly 10 times the CDC's budget for assisting states with lead poisoning.
Universal testing/screening of blood-lead levels for all children: During the writing of this blog post, on June 5, 2019, the Mayor of Philadelphia signed this bill into law that requires providers to test the blood lead levels of the infants they are treating at least twice before the children are 30 months. Pediatricians recommend that children get a blood lead test at around the age of 1 year and again around the age of 2 years. Children who live in older housing or have other risk factors should be screened once a year until the age of six. While The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) requires blood lead testing of all Medicaid enrolled children at 1-2 years of age or at 3 years of age (if not previously tested) this mandate covers all children no matter the insurance coverage.
Lawsuits against paint companies: There has been a movement nationally to bring lawsuits against paint companies that knowingly used and sold toxic lead-based paint before the 1978 ban. A legal fight just ended in California after 18 years, and more legal action in other cities is a proposed method to aid in the high costs of cleaning up lead in the city.
Strengthen registry of licensed landlords: The City of Philadelphia License and Inspections has a property history database that shows the property manager’s permits, licenses, violations and appeals. This registry can be strengthened by taking the necessary steps to increase the number of registered licensed landlords and implementing a section for landlords to prove that their homes are lead-free and safe for occupancy.
Lead Court: A program spearheaded by the Lead and Healthy Homes Program to serve as a vehicle to help renters hold property owners accountable when the housing structure isn’t perceived to be up to code with lead mandates. There have been stories that show this program isn’t as helpful as it should be and needs to be fixed: Read here
Bianca Chun contributed to this post.