
You can’t follow the Stay at Home order if you don’t have a home. As cities across the country plan for the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic and its aftermath, we have a collective responsibility to prioritize keeping families safe and in their homes as the cornerstone of any recovery plan. In Philadelphia, the poorest big city in the country, and the city with the third largest income gap between the wealthy and the poor, the need for emergency housing protections is even more pressing.
Skyrocketing eviction rates and rampant gentrification were already wreaking havoc on low-income communities long before COVID-19 hit. In 2017, 53% of renters in Philadelphia were cost-burdened, meaning they spent more than 30% of their income on rent. Roughly one in every 14 renters in Philadelphia is under threat of eviction each year, and presently there are over 2,000 cases in eviction court waiting to be heard once the Public Health Emergency order is lifted.
I have experienced the affordable housing crisis firsthand. I was raised in the Nicetown neighborhood of Philadelphia, and still live on the same block that I grew up on with my four children. As a young single mother, I paid my way through the Community College of Philadelphia while working as a Nursing Assistant. Later, I began working for Easterseals, where I connected children with disabilities and their families to the programs and resources they needed to thrive.
Then, after 17 years of employment at Easterseals, I was laid off. It was 2011, and former Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett had introduced sweeping budget cuts that eliminated critical programs across the state. I was devastated, and had a difficult time finding employment with a comparable salary that would support me and my growing family. From there, my circumstances quickly spiraled. Unexpectedly, I lost my house to a sheriff’s sale. In what felt like overnight, I went from being gainfully-employed to struggling to pay rent in my own home.
My story bears many similarities to what families are currently experiencing across Philadelphia and across the country. In April of 2020, the national unemployment rate hovered at just below 15%, the highest since the Great Depression. Just like the 2008 recession, families are suddenly faced with potentially paralyzing budget cuts and unprecedented job loss. Austerity and years of targeted disinvestment have ravaged the Black community, and further cuts will undoubtedly decimate the already weakened social safety net that thousands of Philadelphians rely on to get by.
Increases in homelessness and displacement will result in a massive wave of COVID-19 infections, and people of color will be the hardest hit. In my neighborhood of Nicetown, which suffers from severe air pollution as a result of SEPTA’s Midvale Bus Depot, we have a childhood asthma rate of 31%, making residents all the more susceptible to COVID-19. It is not the time for us to ask for further sacrifice and resilience from our hardest hit communities. It is time that we stepped up and prioritized them instead.
Keeping families in their homes is not only good public health policy, it is a logical step in aiding economic recovery. As someone who has lived the destabilizing effects of housing insecurity firsthand, I know that keeping families in their homes is the first step in getting them back on their feet. It is difficult to imagine finding a new job, homeschooling your children, and doing the increased domestic labor that is required to maintain a home during a pandemic if you are also facing homelessness. It is on local and state governments to step up to ensure that our most vulnerable populations are not left behind as we begin to pick up the pieces of our post-COVID-19 world.
That is why I worked with my colleagues Councilmembers Helen Gym and Jamie Gauthier at the citywide level to introduce a set of common-sense protections for renters in Philadelphia. The Emergency Housing Protection Act would prohibit large rent increases for a year after the pandemic, waive late payment fees, extend the eviction moratorium, require mediation prior to eviction proceedings, establish rent repayment plans, and allow renters to recover damages after illegal lockouts. These measures will help families stay in their homes and provide them with needed security during this uncertain time.
However, we know that keeping families in their homes is not the end of the solution. We need to be proactive about lasting strategies to address the health issues faced by working families. Longer term economic stimulus plans should address the need for green jobs and infrastructure; affordable housing; access to quality healthcare; and well-funded public education.
The COVID-19 crisis has laid bare many of the inequities of our current system, but it has also presented us with an opportunity for real change. As a city and as a society we should have the urgency to provide much-needed immediate relief and the courage to fight for structural changes that would make Philadelphia a livable, healthy, and safe city for generations to come.

COVID-19 has rapidly changed our world and altered everyone’s lives. However, no one in our population has been more affected by COVID-19 than people experiencing homelessness and housing insecurity.
Within just a few short weeks so much has been upended. “Social distancing” has entered our collective lexicon. We wait in line to enter the grocery store, only to find they have no flour or toilet paper. We struggle to figure out how to tele-work from home, if we are fortunate enough to remain working at all. For some of us, the effects have been more dramatic: lost jobs, lost incomes, strained relationships, and in too many cases, lost lives.
Consider the plight of people experiencing homelessness. Over the last several weeks:
Low socioeconomic status was identified early on as a risk factor for significant COVID illness. For most of us it is difficult to imagine the day-to-day trials of living without a home during “normal” times. However, the added risk for significant infection, and even greater resource restriction has exacerbated the homeless crisis. Questions persist among people experiencing homelessness such as:
The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted housing security across our communities and the likely increase in the number of Americans that may be facing housing insecurity. Every unsheltered individual has their own story. For many, a sudden and unexpected change in economic circumstances precipitated loss of housing. A portion of the homeless suffer from substance use issues. In some cases, these struggles were a contributing factor in the road towards homeless. I have met many others who turned to substance use as a result of homelessness. Either way, the resources available to help treat and overcome substance use disorder during this pandemic are dramatically restricted. Pharmaceutical agents used in Medication Assisted Treatment (MAT) programs are hard to find. There has been a dramatic reduction in treatment sites that remain open, and limited transportation options make access to these almost impossible for the unsheltered. In some communities, telemedicine programs are replacing in-person meetings, but telemedicine is not a forum that people experiencing homelessness can easily access. This issue persists in the counseling and treatment programs so critical to addressing behavioral health crisis. Organizations such as Alcoholics Anonymous, Narcotics Anonymous, and others are providing virtual meetings, but the unsheltered have almost no means of accessing such services. As a result, their struggles with mental health and substance use are at risk of worsening during this pandemic.
I applaud our social distancing efforts. As a society we have “flattened the curve” of this disease in ways I wouldn’t have thought possible weeks ago. As a result, my healthcare colleagues and I have a fighting chance in our efforts to control this COVID-19. But for our nation’s unsheltered, social distancing is rarely an option. There are communities that have quickly mobilized resources such as impromptu tents, sanitation stations near encampments and local parks, and organized testing within homeless communities, but these have been the exception. We can do better as a society.
While our nation has been struggling with homelessness since well before COVID, the virus has exacerbated the divide between those with and without stable housing. As we reach the peak of COVID infections, and move towards community re-engagement efforts, we have an opportunity to mitigate both pandemics – COVID-19 and homelessness. Perhaps a silver-lining of the last few months lies in our ability to answer these questions:
In my work with vulnerable populations over the last decade, I have participated in multiple community collaborative efforts that have implemented effective practices for at-risk and vulnerable populations. In every case, these have delivered more effective care AND provided dramatic community cost savings (typically due to streamlining of efforts and avoidance of duplication). We have an opportunity to engage in similar efforts as we conduct COVID community re-engagement across our country over the next few months. It is my hope that as a society we can recognize this opportunity, identify the lessons learned, and engage in the efforts that will lead to improved community resources. If so, we will have addressed two major pandemics in relatively short order.

Housing affordability has markedly worsened over the past 15 years, and more American families than ever are struggling to pay the rent and make ends meet. For those at the bottom of the income scale, the problem is most acute: roughly 10 million households with extremely low incomes are either homeless or pay unaffordable rents that force many of them to make untenable choices between paying the rent and paying for other necessities like nutritious food, transportation, and medications.
Out of over 3,000 counties in the nation, there are only 28 counties where a full-time worker earning minimum wage can afford a modest one-bedroom rental home, and there are none where they can afford a modest two-bedroom. A full-time worker earning the federal minimum wage of $7.25 needs to work approximately 127 hours per week for all 52 weeks of the year to afford a two-bedroom rental home at the national average fair market rent. The number of households with “worst-case housing needs” – that is, households with very low incomes that either pay more than half their income for rent or live in severely substandard housing and receive no aid – has risen by 66% since 2001. Nationally, there are only 37 affordable and available homes for every 100 extremely low-income renter households. According to a recent public opinion poll, 60% of Americans say housing affordability is a “serious problem” where they live, which is up an astounding 21 points since 2016 — and that includes majorities in cities, suburbs, and rural areas.
Decades of research demonstrate that stable, affordable homes are linked with better health outcomes across the lifespan (e.g., fewer child hospitalizations, ER visits, developmental delays, asthma cases, and mental health challenges; more preventative care visits; lower Medicaid costs; etc.). Unfortunately, today, millions of people experience housing circumstances that damage their health and, consequently, increase unnecessary health care utilization. These experiences include living in dilapidated/unsafe homes; residential instability such as “couch surfing” or doubling-up with family or friends; struggling to pay rent; living in housing that is located in low-opportunity neighborhoods that lack resources, job opportunities, and strong schools; and experiencing eviction and homelessness. Children’s HealthWatch found that unstable housing among families with children will cost the nation $111 billion in avoidable health-related expenditures over the next 10 years.
Every day, nurse leaders see first-hand the harmful health impacts of unstable and unaffordable housing on their patients. Therefore, they are uniquely positioned to weigh in on housing policy issues and join in the advocacy to make homes affordable for low-income people. Housing advocates and healthcare professionals must recognize that their fates are intertwined and work shoulder-to-shoulder to advance research-based housing solutions. That is exactly what we are doing through Opportunity Starts at Home, an unprecedented campaign that is bringing together leading organizations from housing, health, education, civil rights, food security, criminal justice, and more to urge Congress to finally tackle the housing crisis. The National Nurse-Led Care Consortium certainly understands that good housing is good health, and we are so pleased that it participates on the campaign’s Roundtable alongside so many other powerhouse organizations.
Failures of both public policy and the private market have contributed to today’s crisis, and many public and private institutions must play a role in developing solutions. But among these institutions, the federal government is key. Federal investments in affordable housing have been declining for decades and, today, only one in four households eligible for federal housing assistance receive it due to chronic underfunding. Without action from the federal government, quality affordable homes for the lowest-income people cannot be consistently built, operated, and maintained. The Opportunity Starts at Home campaign has outlined a set of federal policy strategies that are necessary to solve the affordable housing crisis facing America’s poorest households:
While the situation is dire, there is reason to be encouraged. In recent months, several of these ambitious policy concepts have been introduced in congressional legislation. In several cases, such as the Eviction Crisis Act and the Family Stability and Opportunity Vouchers Act, the legislation has been bipartisan, which demonstrates the growing recognition in both parties that housing is inextricably linked to nearly every measure of having a quality life. The political momentum is growing, and powerful new constituencies are forming to ensure that everyone has access to stable, affordable homes.

The spread of novel coronavirus (COVID-19) has drastically changed daily life, both here in the United States and around the world. Many of us are working from home, or are otherwise limiting our interaction with others per the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC) social distancing guidelines to limit transmission. But for those without homes (or whose homes are unsafe or unsecure) the repercussions of the COVID-19 pandemic are particularly salient. Residents of public housing, people experiencing homelessness, and members of low-income communities may lose access to the critical resources they need to survive. As local and state governments ask people to shelter in their homes to avoid spreading this infectious disease, it is apparent now more than ever that housing is health.
The National Healthcare for the Homeless Council notes that people experiencing homelessness tend towards high rates of chronic conditions such as diabetes and lung disease, both of which increase the risk of severe illness from COVID-19 infection. People living in public housing are also at a greater risk during the COVID-19 pandemic. According to a recent Urban Institute report, “over half of households in public housing were headed by a person who was 62 or older and/or was disabled” - two groups that are especially vulnerable to severe illness.
But clinical risk is only one consideration. Low-wage workers will bear the brunt of the economic downturn caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. This means that families struggling to afford rent each month may now be displaced as a result of lay-offs, wage cuts, or slashed hours. Moreover, those experiencing homelessness may be unable to comply with recommendations to limit coronavirus exposure or prepare for potential quarantine. Where can you quarantine if your home is a public place?
Social distancing is currently the best preventive measure to halt the spread of COVID-19. Yet social distancing has implications for those working in “non-essential” industries, those reliant on public services for essentials like food and medicine, and families with young children no longer able to attend school. While social distancing is the correct public health approach to preventing further spread of disease, economically vulnerable communities are facing immediate, catastrophic losses as businesses across the country close their doors for the foreseeable future. Moreover, for people experiencing homelessness and those with disabilities, social distancing poses a daunting - if not insurmountable - challenge.
COVID-19 hasn’t caused these gaps in our healthcare system and housing landscape, but has exposed them and made the need for solutions more urgent for the public’s health. To solve these issues, communities must find creative solutions that address all aspects - social, economic, and health-related - while being grounded in public health and social justice.
Fortunately, some communities are taking steps to mitigate the pandemic’s effects among vulnerable populations. In Philadelphia, the mayor announced the city’s plan to temporarily halt evictions as the number of cases continues to rise throughout the city and its surrounding counties. Other major cities have also taken this critical step. Federal lawmakers are considering emergency measures to support American families during the crisis. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development is prohibiting foreclosures and evictions for homeowners with Federal Housing Finance Agency-backed mortgages. These steps are crucial, but don’t go far enough to provide much-needed relief for many Americans. In addition to addressing the immediate needs arising from this public health crisis, policymakers must consider implementing long-term solutions to the inequities that persist in the public sphere. Social service and community healthcare providers should be involved not only in actualizing guidelines, but in designing thoughtful, client-centered policies and strategies to address the persistent disparities in under-resourced communities.
To that end, what can healthcare providers do - both now and in the future - to respond to the needs of those at greatest risk?
Justin Gero and MaryGrace Joyce contributed to this blog post.