This is the first episode of our new Vaccine Confidence series on At the Core of Care. Over the course of four episodes, we will dive into different facets of the COVID-19 vaccination effort, including education, advocacy, and community partnership.
You can listen to At the Core of Care on the Pennsylvania Action Coalition’s website, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Stay tuned for the rest of the series in the coming weeks by following us on Twitter and subscribing to our newsletter.
In this episode, we hear from Nurses Who Vaccinate founder Melody Butler, RN, who works as an infection preventionist at Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center on Long Island. Melody also joined us in 2021 for our first Vaccine Confidence series. This time, she’s back to talk about where we are in the pandemic, and to weigh in on whether we are more prepared to prevent cases of infectious disease than in previous years.
Melody starts by addressing the “tripledemic.” This winter, we have seen a simultaneous surge of COVID, RSV, and flu. Melody confirms that we are seeing higher-than-normal rates of infection. At the time of the recording—January 24th, 2023—there had been 85 pediatric deaths from flu this season, nearly double the number of deaths from last winter.
Meanwhile, COVID vaccination rates have plateaued. “Last we spoke, the vaccination rates for United States at the end of 2021 were about 73 percent for people having had received at least one dose of the COVID vaccine. And here we are in 2023 and we're at a whopping 81 percent of people having at least one vaccine dose. So, I'm very disappointed to see where we are right now” Melody says. The vaccination rate in children under five is only 11 percent.
The conversation shifts to the bivalent booster rollout. Melody sees several reasons why not enough people are up-to-date with their vaccinations. First, many people do not know they’re eligible for a new vaccine, or forget they need a booster. People may be too busy to take off work to get the booster. When primary care doctors don’t provide the shot in their office and recommend going to a pharmacy, people may not schedule that extra appointment. Some people are afraid of the side effects, which can necessitate time off work. Many employers are being less lenient with giving time off than they were earlier in the pandemic.
The end of the Public Health Emergency Declaration is another threat to the vaccine rollout. Many services that are currently free, such as COVID tests, will no longer be free starting in May 2023. Millions of people may lose their Medicaid coverage this year, meaning lost pathways to free testing, vaccines, and treatments. Hospitals will no longer receive reimbursement for treating uninsured patients with COVID-19.
Overall, there is less support and more barriers keeping people from taking action against the spread of COVID-19. As Melody says, we are getting away from the “all hands on deck” mentality that we learned in the early days of the pandemic. The long-term management of COVID-19 and other infectious diseases is going to require employers and healthcare organizations to “highly encourage self-care.”
As the country moves on, nurses and other health professionals will have an uphill battle to prevent COVID cases. They will have to push against misinformation, especially as social media platforms change how they regulate misinformation. Nurses are also warding off “hopelessness” among patients, Melody claims. “People are very disappointed that the COVID vaccine does not prevent illness. We have to stress how amazing it is that the vaccine keeps you out of the hospital just like the flu shot…. that's such an important point that we need to stress to the public, to our patients, to our communities.”
Melody is the founding member of Nurses Who Vaccinate, an organization for nurses and healthcare workers who are passionate about vaccines. You can follow Nurses Who Vaccinate on Twitter or attend one of their upcoming events.
Nurses and other health professionals across the country are using innovative methods to vaccinate their communities against COVID-19. Follow along as we explore other professionals’ stories as part of our Vaccine Confidence Series.
----------
This project was funded in part by a cooperative agreement with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (grant number NU50CK000580). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The contents of this resource center do not necessarily represent the policy of CDC or HHS, and should not be considered an endorsement by the Federal Government.
This episode and blog post are Part 1 of the final special report of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports series on At the Core of Care. Over the course of 6 episodes, we'll do a deep dive into three different facets of the COVID-19 vaccination effort. Stay tuned for Part 2 of this special report in the coming weeks by following us on Twitter and subscribing to our newsletter.
Lizett Leandro is the Director of Clinical Services for a senior living non-profit in Southern California. She oversees nursing education policy and procedures and quality improvement for skilled nursing facilities and assisted living communities in Southern California.
Leandro spent the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic working with older adults, and her own experiences as a nurse made it clear to her that vaccine education was an important first step to getting people vaccinated and controlling COVID-19 in California. Early in the vaccine rollout she witnessed skepticism, “mainly because we just didn't have the material… the correct material from the credible sources on hand,” Leandro observes. “So I started gathering all that material. I started making myself available, as a nurse, to our staff.” Flyers were an especially valuable tool for Leandro, because they answered common questions using understandable terms. Leandro noticed a big shift once people started understanding the science behind the vaccines.
She witnessed first-hand how much hope the vaccine brought patients, she says, “especially [in] the assisted living communities, memory care communities, skilled nursing facilities to have more resident-to-resident interaction, more families involved. More human touch, personal touch. More activities.” Now about 95% of the residents of these living communities are vaccinated, and Leandro reports that things are looking brighter.
By Spring 2021, Leandro got involved with HealthImpact to help get its Trust a Nurse, Ask a Nurse telehealth platform up and running. This free service is still available and relies on nurses who volunteer to speak with community members through video calls. “We first have a video call with them and explain what it is, answer all the questions, and then we follow up with the material just to solidify the patient education,” says Leandro. She adds that when someone has internet access issues, “we literally send it right to their phone.”
The program has received many calls from women and lactation consultants who are hearing misinformation or have questions about breastfeeding and the vaccine. Leandro herself had a baby in the first year of the pandemic, and shares, “I had done a lot of research on the benefits of breastfeeding along with, you know, what it was to breastfeed with the COVID-19 vaccine and if it had any impact. So being able to share material from facts from the research from CDC, from CDPH. That it was actually encouraged to breastfeed…and all the benefits of breastfeeding of course were highlighted. It really spoke to me on how lack of education and access to information is such a big factor in vaccine hesitancy, you know, and how providing this education to the right person can make a difference.”
Trust a Nurse, Ask a Nurse also offers all of their materials in Spanish. “One of the visitors that I had was bilingual, so being able to provide Spanish material and English material-- it was really invaluable because I spoke to one person, but that conversation actually impacted you know, probably 10, 20 other people. Because I know she was going to take that material to other people,” Leandro shares. Providing education to just one vaccine-hesitant patient could have a significant impact on a community that Leandro might not have reached otherwise.
Trust a Nurse, Ask a Nurse has had many successes, and Leandro remains optimistic that vaccination rates will continue to climb, even with current misinformation circulating that the vaccines are ineffective at preventing breakthrough cases. Leandro responds “the most valuable tools that we can get… is having one more tool to prevent death, to prevent severe COVID. I think our nursing community or healthcare community, we have to stay grounded to that fact, you know and understand that, yes, COVID is not going anywhere. But the science is also not going anywhere.”
Nurses and other health professionals across the country are using innovative methods to vaccinate their communities against COVID-19. Follow along as we explore other stories in depth as part of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports.
----------
This project was funded in part by a cooperative agreement with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (grant number NU50CK000580). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The contents of this resource center do not necessarily represent the policy of CDC or HHS, and should not be considered an endorsement by the Federal Government.
This episode and blog post are Part 2 of the second special report of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports series on At the Core of Care. Over the course of 6 episodes, we'll do a deep dive on three different facets of the COVID-19 vaccination effort. Stay tuned for new episodes in the coming weeks by following us on Twitter and subscribing to our newsletter.
Dr. Dewi Brown-DeVeaux joins us to continue this special report’s discussion on burnout in nursing. As a Director of Nursing at a major academic Medical Center in New York City, Dr. Brown-DeVeaux is a leader whose two main roles are to develop a healthy organizational structure and to serve as a liaison between nurses, patients, and other executive leadership. She works to stay in tune with her nurses’ needs and builds supportive environments for staff and patients. The pandemic has amplified this part of her role. “My job turned into 70% support,” she says.
When asked about the major causes of burnout, Dr. Brown-DeVeaux says COVID-19 is still the biggest factor. “Providers are currently at the mercy of the unvaccinated,” she says. Healthcare providers anticipated that the development of a vaccine would be a “triumph” over the pandemic. Many healthcare workers were motivated to power through until a vaccine became available. By now, vaccines have been available to most adults for almost a year, and still many people remain unvaccinated. This has led to persistent COVID-19-induced stress among nurses today.
We also ask Dr. Brown-Deveaux to share what she would tell a nurse who is frustrated by those who remain unvaccinated. Dr. Brown-DeVeaux believes in meeting people where they are, and she is optimistic that enough people will be vaccinated when they feel they are ready to make that decision. She encourages nurses to have conversations to understand where the patient is in their decision-making, rather than where the nurse wants the patient to be.
As a leader in the field, Dr. Brown-DeVeaux’s role is to provide platforms for patient-provider conversations about the vaccine. One way she’s done this is to go directly into neighborhoods. The Greater New York City Black Nurses Association, of which Dr. Brown-DeVeaux is a member, partnered with FEMA to provide outreach in African American communities. Cultivating an environment where people can ask questions and feel that their concerns are heard can allow meaningful change to occur.
Dr. Brown-DeVeaux is still attempting to increase vaccine confidence among nurses, too. While some nurses are skeptical of conflicting information about the vaccine, Dr. Brown-DeVeaux believes that practicing medicine requires trust in science and a commitment to the common good. She also says that vaccines are a “gift.” Getting vaccinated is the best way to ease the anxiety around COVID-19 and reach the end of this pandemic, and is the greatest gift a person can give to a nurse who is burned out.
If you are a nurse, Dr. Brown-DeVeaux reminds you to address burnout when it creeps in. Sustained, high levels of stress can cause depression and anxiety, and so it is important to find the help you need. Likewise, “take care of each other on a continuous basis.” Dr. Brown Deveaux says that asking someone if they need help feels good and can go a long way in improving workplace culture.
Nurses and other health professionals across the country are using innovative methods to vaccinate their communities against COVID-19. Follow along as we explore their stories in depth as part of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports.
----------
This project was funded in part by a cooperative agreement with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (grant number NU50CK000580). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The contents of this resource center do not necessarily represent the policy of CDC or HHS, and should not be considered an endorsement by the Federal Government.
This episode and blog post are Part 1 of the second special report of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports series on At the Core of Care. Over the course of 6 episodes, we'll do a deep dive on three different facets of the COVID-19 vaccination effort. Stay tuned for new episodes in the coming weeks by following us on Twitter and subscribing to our newsletter.
We spend this episode and the next hearing nursing views on the impact of burnout, the pandemic’s role, and paths forward. Dr. Ali Tayyeb is our guest for this episode. He is a nurse and a veteran with a specialty in combat trauma. Today, he is a Professor of Nursing at California State University Los Angeles and the host of a podcast called RN Mentor.
We ask Dr. Tayyeb to describe nursing burnout in the workforce around him. However, he doesn’t even use the term “burnout” anymore. “Burndown,” he says, depicts a clearer image of the system that causes burnout amongst nurses. The individual nurses he sees getting overwhelmed are the last link in a chain that starts with how hospitals are run.
Prior to the pandemic, many hospitals were understaffing nurses. Dr Tayyeb explains, “that means we have the minimum number of people that are available. And when one or two of those people all of a sudden are out of that system, the system really feels it.” The addition of the COVID-19 pandemic and repeated waves of hospitalizations forced nurses into high-stress situations, with staffing issues contributing to an already shaky foundation. Burnout, or burndown if you prefer, is a systemic issue.
Dr. Tayyeb notes the social and emotional nature of nursing work as another root cause of burndown. Nurses “tend to deal more with the patients, with their families…. establish more of a relationship with those individuals. So when things go wrong, or things don't go the way they expect, it's a more personal kind of let down with them with that nurse.” The patient-provider relationships intrinsic to nursing can infringe on nurses’ wellbeing.
At this moment in the pandemic, as nurses and other healthcare providers continue to promote vaccine confidence, they are increasingly providing critical care for unvaccinated COVID-19 patients. Dr. Tayyeb notices a different tone toward healthcare staff. He says, “now the people that we're seeing coming through the door are the anti-vaxxers, anti-maskers. And with that comes the mentality of being resistant to the healthcare system, the nurses and physicians that are trying to help you. And it just doesn't make sense for us.” Dr. Tayyeb lists some of the ways unvaccinated COVID-19 patients can endanger hospital patients and staff.
Building vaccine confidence is a critical step in reducing pandemic-related burndown in the healthcare system. But nurses will need institutional support to address burn down and to build sustainable working environments going forward. Pay, staffing, and adequate resources will continue to shape the work environment.
Later in the episode, Dr. Tayyeb shares his personal outlets to manage pandemic-related stress. In response to the surge of deaths among hospital workers in 2020, he built a giant papier-mâché sculpture, using quotes from news headlines and the stethoscopes of real nurses. “About 400 hours or so went into making this and it was really therapeutic for me. It was a way for me to understand and grasp what was going on in the world. But it was also a way for me to try to share that,” says Dr. Tayyeb. The sculpture circulated newspapers and journals across California and brought attention to the needs of hospital staff.
As a nursing professor, Dr. Tayyeb was disheartened by the lack of educational opportunities for his virtual students. He began recording conversations with healthcare professionals to show his nursing class what was going on during the pandemic. These conversations are now a part of a podcast, called RN Mentor, that Ali Tayyeb hosts. If you enjoy At the Core of Care, please check out RN Mentor wherever you listen to podcasts.
Nurses and other health professionals across the country are using innovative methods to vaccinate their communities against COVID-19. Follow along as we explore their stories in depth as part of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports.
----------
This project was funded in part by a cooperative agreement with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (grant number NU50CK000580). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The contents of this resource center do not necessarily represent the policy of CDC or HHS, and should not be considered an endorsement by the Federal Government.