This episode and blog post are Part 2 of the first special report of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports series on At the Core of Care. Over the course of 6 episodes, we'll do a deep dive on three different facets of the COVID-19 vaccination effort. Stay tuned for new episodes in the coming weeks by following us on Twitter and subscribing to our newsletter.
In this episode, we hear from Dr. Paula Milone-Nuzzo from Boston, who has an extensive career in academia as both a professor and an executive administrator. Paula is currently a professor and the president of Mass General Hospital's MGH Institute of Health Professions. In this episode, Dr. Milone-Nuzzo joins us to discuss the current workforce crisis in healthcare and the continued need to reframe training and education for the health professions. We’ll also explore solutions that could help cultivate more support, resilience and retention.
Dr. Milone-Nuzzo has seen decades of nursing workforce changes over her career. She started working in homecare in the 1980’s, and watched as more hospitals bought home-visiting practices and as more resources were funneled into homecare nursing over the 1980’s and 1990’s. During this time, she taught at the first homecare program for advanced practice nurses in the country, preparing a new generation of homecare nurses. Dr. Milone-Nuzzo’s well-trained eye keeps her alert to nursing workforce changes happening now. COVID-19, she says, is just a catalyst for changes that were underway long before the pandemic hit. “We already knew that we were going to be facing some shortages as more baby boomer registered nurses are retiring. There's just a nursing shortage in general. You know we were in a crisis mode before the pandemic. But …. it's really amplified now.”
Many healthcare workers are starting to feel burned out, ready to leave the field, and unable to meet the needs of their families and friends outside of work. Dr. Milone-Nuzzo explains “this blow with Omicron has really put a level of uncertainty in everyone's perspective. And I think that makes it even harder to practice effectively.” She notes other stressors, including pay equity, as compounding factors in nurses’ decision to stay or leave the profession.
Dr. Milone-Nuzzo offers short-term solutions for moments of crisis like this; the first is staffing. In order to decrease the stress of nurses, it is crucial that hospitals bring in additional resources. Years ago, many hospitals decided to eliminate LPNs. Dr. Milone-Nuzzo argues that bringing LPNs back into the acute care setting might reduce the stress of RNs on staff.
Long-term, Dr. Milone-Nuzzo says the future stability of the workforce depends on nursing students. Many hospitals and universities paused their clinical placement partnerships due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Students were seen as a burden to train and supervise at a time when hospitals were already overwhelmed. This reduced the number of nurses entering the workforce and amplified the nursing shortages we attribute to the pandemic. Clinical placement partnerships should be an opportunity to support nurses and stabilize the workforce long-term. Dr. Milone-Nuzzo proposes that stronger training programs would better prepare students to enter their clinical placements without demanding so much from their mentors.
Academic nursing programs should also be building workforce resilience through course curricula. It is important to help students learn how to take care of themselves, how to recognize when they need help, and where to get help. Along with building academic programs, it is imperative that academic institutions increase enrollment. Paula states that 80,000 qualified nursing applicants are turned away every year. The healthcare system needs more nurses, and so the workforce needs to grow to meet this need. “That's going to require sometimes changes in legislation, sometimes changes in statute, sometimes changes in accreditation standards. All of that is possible, because we are in a new area of healthcare.”
Nurses and other health professionals across the country are using innovative methods to vaccinate their communities against COVID-19. Follow along as we explore their stories in depth as part of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports.
----------
This project was funded in part by a cooperative agreement with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (grant number NU50CK000580). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The contents of this resource center do not necessarily represent the policy of CDC or HHS, and should not be considered an endorsement by the Federal Government.
This episode and blog post are Part 1 of the first special report of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports series on At the Core of Care. Over the course of 6 episodes, we'll do a deep dive on three different facets of the COVID-19 vaccination effort. Stay tuned for new episodes in the coming weeks by following us on Twitter and subscribing to our newsletter.
In this episode, we hear from Carl Hinson, the Director of Workforce Development for Hawaii Pacific Health. He explains that his organization has enlisted high school students to help vaccinate community members and converted motor coach buses into mobile vaccine clinics.
Hawaii has unique challenges to healthcare delivery. Most of the islands of Hawaii are considered rural, due to their physical distance and lack of specialty care providers. Recruiting healthcare staff proved challenging before the pandemic. As Carl explains, “our challenge is that we have 2,500 miles of water between us and the nearest landmass.” The pandemic only exacerbated workforce shortages. Several training programs shut down, reducing the number of medical assistant graduates from over 400 to under 100.
Carl had begun piloting high-school-based medical system training programs prior to the pandemic. Nursing training programs, surgical instrument processing tech programs, and patient service representative programs have been placed into high schools to develop Hawaii’s healthcare workforce. The program has been highly successful; 18 high schools in Hawaii now offer the program, and 100% of the program’s graduates receive national certification as medical assistants.
When the Department of Health asked Pacific Health to help with vaccine distribution, Carl quickly turned to his school partners for help. Principals and school staff were supportive of hosting high-school-based vaccination sites. Carl ensured that students of the medical system training programs were taught how to provide IM injections. Then students were staffed alongside nurses and medical assistants to administer vaccinations. “These were seniors in high school that were not only vaccinating their peers in school, but then their parents would come,” says Carl. It was a win-win for the medical assistant program and for the community.
But Carl and his team acknowledged barriers to vaccine access, and wanted to improve vaccine distribution to hard-to-reach populations. Hawaii has many transportation services to accommodate tourism. He contacted a bus company that had offered transportation services to Pacific Health. “Why not try to see if we can't retrofit a bus or two, make it a vaccination center, and then it carries all the supplies from one location to the other?” The bus partner agreed to provide a bus, and just two weeks later the first mobile vaccination bus “Vax Squad” launched. The bus was staffed with both experienced and new medical assistants, including students who had recently finished the medical assistant program. To date, three buses have delivered 40,000 vaccinations to communities around Hawaii.
This project was successful because of pre-existing partnerships, according to Carl.
Later in the episode, we hear from Maria Saldiva in Texas. Maria is currently a clinical assistant professor at UT Health San Antonio School of Nursing, and a family nurse practitioner at the college’s Wellness 360 Clinic. Maria is also a member of the National Nurse-Led Care Consortium’s Vaccine Confidence Advisory Committee. She describes the services that Wellness 360 Clinic offers, and the diverse community of students she serves. She also shares how UT Health San Antonio managed testing, vaccinations and most recently the latest isolation guidelines. She also talks about the uptick in provider visits when patients test positive and navigating when it’s safe to return to school or work on campus.
Nurses and other health professionals across the country are using innovative methods to vaccinate their communities against COVID-19. Follow along as we explore their stories in depth as part of our Vaccine Confidence Special Reports.
----------
This project was funded in part by a cooperative agreement with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (grant number NU50CK000580). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The contents of this resource center do not necessarily represent the policy of CDC or HHS, and should not be considered an endorsement by the Federal Government.
The work of nurse leaders from our Vaccine Confidence Advisory Committee (VCAC) was recently featured in local newspapers across the country. The VCAC was launched in April 2021 by the National Nurse-Led Care Consortium (NNCC) as part of a cooperative agreement with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to increase COVID-19 vaccine confidence among nurses and their patients. NNCC conducted a national search for nurses who could inform our work from a diverse set of communities across the U.S.
The VCAC is comprised of 20 nurses of varying roles and healthcare settings from a variety of communities. Together, they work to raise awareness of the barriers around equitable vaccine education and access. Some of these nurse leaders are highlighted below:
Kentucky's The News Enterprise featured Joyce Johnson , who discussed her work as an advanced practice nurse, her participation in the VCAC, and her advocacy to promote NNCC’s Nurses Make Change Happen campaign. Johnson, who works with patients with substance use disorders, emphasized the importance of making sure that voice was heard in the campaign. “I have a very vulnerable patient population and I’m always looking for times that I can be an advocate for them and times that I can increase awareness of the needs of this group,” she said. Johnson was also recently featured in NNCC's Nurses Make Change Happen nurse stories.
In Dover, Delaware, family nurse practitioner Evelyn Crump expressed a similar sense of urgency to Bay to Bay News. “I know that vaccines save lives,” Dr. Crump said. “So I want to do the best that I can and offer the most up-to-date scientific information to patients.” Dr. Crump has also worked to promote NNCC’s Nurses Make Change Happen Toolkit, which provides resources, shareable images, and social media content for nurses to help launch conversations around vaccine hesitancy. Of the toolkit, NNCC’s Senior Director of Strategic Initiatives, Kristine Gonnella, says, “We recognize how quickly misinformation can spread. We’re trying to address that head-on and dispel some of the myths around this vaccine.”
In Flagstaff, Arizona, Janet Reich is similarly dedicated to combatting misinformation. As a school nurse on a Navajo reservation and a former clinical researcher on pediatric vaccines, Reich is eager to explain the breadth and depth of research behind the COVID-19 vaccines. On her years as a research associate, she told the Arizona Daily Sun, “We were boots-on-the-ground watchdogs. We were the ones that go into the (trial) sites, train them, oversee them and make sure the data is clean and accurate. Being in that role, I am intimately aware of what all goes into these studies on vaccines and can help people understand better what emergency approval means.”
In an interview for Vaccine Voices, Vaccine Confidence Advisory Committee member, Melody Butler, BSN, RN, discussed combatting misinformation in the push to vaccinate more nurses. “We’re trying to encourage nurses to be more vocal, maybe on their social media pages, maybe at their workplace speaking up during a lunch break or just ending a conversation when people are spreading misinformation,” Butler says.
NNCC and the VCAC will continue to work towards a world where everyone is vaccinated against COVID-19. “Nurses are often behind the scenes getting the work done,” says Gonnella. “We really saw this as an opportunity to elevate the role nurses have played over time and the role nurses are playing currently within the COVID-19 pandemic to promote vaccine confidence to get us to a brighter, post-COVID future.”
Click here to access NNCC’s #NursesMakeChangeHappen COVID Vaccine Toolkit.
In this episode, we hear from Dr. Meriam Caboral-Stevens, a nurse practitioner, researcher, and faculty member at Eastern Michigan University School of Nursing and Eastern Michigan University’s Center for Health Disparities Innovations and Studies.
Dr. Caboral-Stevens has been activie in CDC’s COVID-19 vaccination initiative, and specifically works to expand vaccination in Asian American and Arab American communities. She describes this effort as having three components: finding and equipping trusted messengers to those communities, creating partnerships between the community and vaccine providers, and communication about the safety and efficacy of the vaccine. She has worked on 10 mass vaccination clinics since the project began in April 2021.
This work has not existed without barriers. Dr. Caboral-Stevens describes issue with transportation, access to technology, and language differences. Cultural humility has been key for her as a Catholic Filipino woman working with Muslim populations. One mass vaccination event was run within a mosque. There is also work done to debunk myths and misconceptions about the vaccine that exist in these communities.
With a goal of getting more young people vaccinated, Dr. Caboral-Stevens’s team has focused on strategies to inform young adults about the safety of the vaccine, including coordinating with social media influencers as trusted messengers. Rather than general information, they work with messengers to discuss what they would like their community to hear and learn.
In discussing how the pandemic will change the healthcare system, Dr. Caboral-Stevens points to one major issue: telehealth. “Before COVID-19, telehealth was kind of like a buzzword…but the majority of health institutions did not have infrastructures for telemedicine or telehealth. I think it will be one of the things that systems and providers will have to embrace…telehealth is here to stay.”
----------
This project was funded in part by a cooperative agreement with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (grant number NU50CK000580). The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). The contents of this resource center do not necessarily represent the policy of CDC or HHS, and should not be considered an endorsement by the Federal Government.